According to Every Avenue at Bottom Lounge in Chicago, IL, on 2018-12-27, "Where Were You" is the only tune that was played from the Ah! EP! I also found out that they played in Omaha, NE, on my birthday in 2012: Every Avenue at Sokol Underground in Omaha, NE, on 2012-12-04.
Editor's Note: The last concert listed on setlist.fm at the Sokol Underground is 2019-11-08. It was John 5, who is now playing guitar in Motley Crue and Jared James Nichols. However, neither the John 5 setlist nor the Jared James Nichols pages list a single tune.
I did a little poking around about the music scene in Omaha, NE, and found a Wikipedia page. Notice the link to a band called Father, which links to a band called Father that is located in Croatia:
